Guest Theory by Chelsea: Toby Theory

alison stink bomb pll

I know this is very fare fetched and random but anything can happen on Pretty Little Liars as we all know. But I would love and hate if this was true (probably not!).

So here it goes…

I think Toby has a twin brother called Charles! (apparently Spencer figures out an anagram in season finale that says it) and “CHARLES” was the one Alison saw with Jenna when she threw the sparkler into the shed! And it blinded both of them! And that’s why at the centre for blind people it said C.Cavanaugh! This would make sense to be Toby’s motive as twins are very close mentally!

View More