What’s the story with Pastor Ted?
His first appearance was in That Girl is Poison, where he met Ashley whilst volunteering at the rummage sale. He shares his cookie with Ashley and they talk about Hanna, he looks around to Hanna and seems to know who she is. He was keen on getting to know the Marins a bit, but was there more to it?
When Hanna finds Emily’s jacket in the pile of clothes that someone left next to her, he watches as she puts the jacket in her bag. Pastor Ted comes by to ask her about it and she hands over the money for it. Did he put the jacket in the clothes?
In The Remains of A, Pastor Ted plans a church party why did he want Hanna to be there, it seems like he is trying to find out more about Hanna. Does he know who she is, is that why he came to Rosewood to find out about Hanna. Maybe he has come to tear the mother and daughter apart?
In Crazy, Ella watches as Ted swirls the spoon around his ice cream, in the previous episode ending A is eating ice cream and looking for at a ‘Room to rent’. Is it a coincidence that Pastor Ted has a sweet tooth as does A?
Ella says that she has never met a Pastor who goes ‘boogie-boarding in Samoa’. Is this a coincidence or could this mean he is the real board-shorts?
Look at Pastor Ted’s shirt that’s folded into his jeans in this picture below.
It looks similar to what the man is wearing in this drawing. Could it represent Pastor Ted and his family?
Ted gave Ashley the flash drive with all of the videos on it which he found at the church, so he knows all of their secrets and could be blackmailing them about it.
We know Pastor Ted’s relationship with Ashley and Ella but did he know Mrs DiLaurentis?
He could be Bethany/Sara Havey’s father who has come to find out what happened to his daughter.
But what if he isn’t anyone’s dad? What if he is Marion’s brother and Toby’s uncle. Could it be that Bethany was also Marion’s child. The drawing above could be of Marion and Ted as children with their parents. If Ted is A then he would lead Toby to his mother’s death. He would get revenge on everyone who helped cover up Marion’s fall including Wilden and Eddie. Especially Mrs. D and Ali. The only reason he is after the girls is because all their parents were involved somehow?
If he’s not a brother, he could be Marion’s lover and Toby’s and Bethany’s real dad? At this stage he could be anyone!
Was he the one that put the money in the bibles?
Let me know your thoughts on Pastor Ted, could he be A?